Messy books
An IRS or State Letter Has Arrived and the Books Cannot Answer It
The letter asks how a number was arrived at, and nobody can say. Note the response date, do not ignore it, and let us build the records the answer has to come from.
First, read what it is
Most letters are not audits. Many are automated: income reported to the IRS by a bank, a customer or a payment processor does not match what the return shows, or a return is missing, or a payment is late. Each letter states what it is about, what is proposed, and the date by which to respond.
The date matters more than anything else on the page. A proposed change that goes unanswered generally becomes final, and the options narrow after that. If more time is needed to assemble records, it can usually be requested, but it has to be requested before the date passes. What to do with an IRS notice explains the common types.
Why messy books make it worse
- An income mismatch can only be explained if the books show what each deposit was
- Unmatched transfers and loan deposits look like unreported income until shown otherwise
- An expense can only be supported if it can be traced to a payment and a purpose
- A return prepared from totals cannot show how the totals were built
- Without records, the proposed figure tends to stand
Put the other way round: reconciled books, with each deposit identified and each large expense supported, answer most letters on their own.
What we do
- Read the letter and tell you in plain terms what it is asking and by when
- Pull your IRS transcripts to see what was reported and what has been assessed
- Rebuild and reconcile the books for the year in question, starting with the items the letter raises
- Identify every deposit, so transfers, loans and owner money are separated from income
- Assemble the documents that support the figures
- Prepare the response, or a corrected return if the original was wrong
Sometimes the rebuilt books show the IRS is right, and the answer is to agree and deal with the balance. Sometimes they show the return was fine and the mismatch has an explanation. Sometimes they show you overpaid. You are told which, with the numbers.
Who speaks to the IRS
We read the notice, build the records and prepare the response or the returns it calls for. Where a matter requires professional representation, including an examination, that is handled by the independent licensed CPA we work with, with our office coordinating. See IRS audit help and tax resolution.
Frequently asked questions
I got an IRS letter about my business income and my books are a mess. What do I do first?
Note the response date and do not ignore the letter. Then get the letter and your records to someone who can read both. The books for the year in question are rebuilt first, starting with the specific items the letter raises. See what to do with an IRS notice.
Can I get more time to respond?
Often, yes, but it has to be requested before the response date. A request that explains records are being assembled is usually better received than silence.
Should I send the IRS my bank statements as they are?
Not without knowing what they show. Raw statements with unexplained deposits and transfers can raise more questions than they answer. The deposits should be identified and the response organized around what the letter asks.
Will you represent me in an audit?
We build the books and the supporting records and prepare the response. Representation in an examination is provided by the independent licensed CPA we work with, and our office coordinates with them throughout. See IRS audit help.
Not the question you had? The full tax FAQ covers more ground, and our client reviews say what the work is actually like.
Related situations and guides
Unfiled returns and no books
Returns went unfiled because the numbers were never there. Books first, then every open return.
Learn moreMissing receipts and records
Lost statements and no receipts. What can be replaced, from where, and which deductions need more.
Learn morePayment apps and processors
Square, Stripe, PayPal, Venmo, Cash App, Shopify. Tying net deposits back to gross sales and the 1099-K.
Learn moreToo many bank accounts
Several accounts and cards with money moving between them. Mapping, matching transfers and reconciling each one.
Learn moreCleanup Planner
Eight questions, then a plan: what comes first, what to gather, and which guides apply.
Part of Messy Books Help, alongside our catch-up bookkeeping service.
Tell us what you need
Send a short note about your situation and we’ll come back to you with a straight answer — whether that’s a quote, a next step, or a referral if it isn’t something we handle.
Prefer to talk it through first? Book a consultation and we’ll find a time, in the Easley office or virtually.
Send us the mess. We will send back a plan.
Call (864) 781-4035 or book a consultation, in the Easley office or virtually.